Did segregation improve the status of African Amer

4 PAGES
1022 WORDS
Read the full essay 1022 words
Did segregation improve the status of African Americans after the Civi

Did Racial Segregation Improve the Status of African Americans?


Whites were there because they chose to be; blacks were there because they had no choice. (p. 158) This quote, from the essay written by Howard N. Rabinowitz, encompasses many, if not all of the ideas that go along with racial segregation.  It is a well-known fact that racial segregation did create a separate and subordinate status for blacks, however, seeing as how at the turn of the century the integration of blacks and whites was a seemingly unrealistic idea, segregation could be seen as somewhat of an improvement from the blacks previous position in the U.S. as slaves.  
Everything is forgiven in the South but color. (p. 159) On the contrary to the above ideas, this quote, spoken by a black woman in Alabama, and seen in Leon F. Litwacks essay opposing the idea that segregation improved the status of African Americans; shows how blacks in the late 19th and early 20th centuries were characterized by increased inequality because of their skin color.  What is looked at as an improvement by Rabinowitz is seen as an informal code of exclusion and discrimination (p. 160) by Litwack.
Although congress reconstructed the exclusion policy in 1867, many white Southerners still remained committed to the exclusion policy.  As a result of this, the military and other forces, to grant new privileges and services to blacks, forced the whites.  After all, segregation was the alternative to integration, and whites didnt want integration. In Rabinowitzs essay, entitled From Exclusion to Segregation:  Southern Race Relations, 1865-1890, many examples are shown in regards to how the exclusion of blacks was transformed into the segregation of blacks from whites.  Some examples of this were seen in bars, athletic events, parks, trains, etc.  An idea was presented by certain Republicans that said that separate provisions for blacks was not a violation of civil rights as long as the facilities and accommodations were equal to those of whites.  Rabinowitz states:  They [blacks] accepted segregation because it was seen as an improvement over exclusion and because they believed, or at least hoped, that separate facilities could be equal. (p. 156) The segregation of blacks was also seen by Rabinowitz as the chance to form a group identity among blacks.  When the white community persisted in its policy of exclusion, blacks responded by opening up their own hospitals, orphanages, hotels, ice cream parlors, and skating rinks. (p. 157) Although these actions cant really be compared to the racism shown by whites, by implementing their own establishments, blacks showed that they too could contribute to the separation of blacks and whites.  
  The Black Codes, as well as the few segregation laws that were passed by the post Civil war government, failed to carry on through the Reconstruction period.  What Litwack saw, as stated in his essay entitled White Folks:  Acts, to be their replacement, was not racial integration, but an informal code of exclusion and discrimination.  (p. 160) A black South Caroliner states, the white people couldnt master these niggers any more so they took up the task of intimidating them. (p.160) Litwack is showing here that as a result of the eradication of slavery from the United States, whites felt as if they no longer had control over the blacks and therefore felt the need to find some way to still master them without owning them.  It is evident, from the examples that Litwack provides in his essay that segregation caused many confrontations between whites and blacks.  Although there were supposed to be separate but equal facilities for both blacks and whites, in many situations that was not the case.  For example, Litwack points out that many of the public parks entrances had signs that stated: Negroes and dogs not allowed. (p. 163) Not only did this still endorse the exclusion of the blacks from public parks, it also classified blacks as being equivalent to dogs.  These signs as well as all other aspects of segregation were neither mentally accepted or emotionally approved by blacks, however, it was followed to facilitate one thing:  survival.  Segregation made for a life of difficulty for the blacks, as